That's very liberal of you
By Emmett on Thursday, October 26 2006, 14:15 - Permalink
It used to be that an act of generosity or mercy would be called "christian" by many. I've always thought that was poor word choice, because those actions aren't really in particularly Christian. "Frank led me to Jesus by his great love of Christ. That was very Christian of him": good word choice. "Frank let me borrow his lawnmower. That was very Christian of him": poor word choice. It's an important word choice as well, because it implies that non-Christians lack those traits and belief that outsiders lack generic positive traits is a symptom of unwarranted discrimination and prejudice.
Luckily, nowadays you don't hear that phrasing very often. It sounds slightly archaic. But I recently overheard something here in San Francisco that disturbed me. Someone said "He helped me set up the event; he's a real liberal." Liberal here is being used in the same sense as Christian; a place holder for "good". This is disturbing because it implies that the members of this culture actually believe that conservatives lack personal, positive traits. That's simply not true, and it's foolish to think otherwise. That kind of attitude is exactly what we should be fighting: people are people, good and bad, no matter what their religion or politics are. Neither Christians nor liberals have any monopoly on kindness.
Comments
I think that's an act of radical misinterpretation followed by some unjustified conclusions. When I've heard people speak this way, they mean "liberal" in a self-deprecating, I'm-ashamed-of-my-own-liberal-guilt kind of way. But even if they believed that liberalism genuinely required people to help set up events, that doesn't mean they believe conservatives wouldn't.
More generally, is pointing out one justification for an act implicitly deprecating all others? I don't think so. If I say, "He gave that rich ugly woman a hug; that was really mercenary of him." does that imply there are non-mercenaries can't hug? Come on.
Perhaps giving more context surrounding the event would make the situation more clear. This wasn't simply overheard in passing, it was part of a larger conversation. Only that phrase really stuck in my mind, so I can't give a transcript, but it was very clear from the context that he was using "liberal" as a synonym for "good".
I've definitely heard people refer to themselves as liberal in the self-deprecating way you mention here, but this wasn't that.
As for the question of the hugging mercenary, that's a different case. Mercenary is in that case being used with it's normal meaning, willing to perform (perhaps untasteful) acts for money. If you said "that was really liberal of him" in that situation, it would sound strangely pejorative of liberals.
Personally, I find this to be an uncompelling objection, since "liberal" actually means "generous" in a completely apolitical sense. Using it that way is no more a statement of bias than saying that someone dresses conservatively.
Again, the context is extremely important. I really wish I remembered the rest of the conversation well enough to replicate it here, but it was clear they were using liberal in a political sense, not in the sense of "liberal with his time".
If you said "that was really liberal of him" in that situation, it would sound strangely pejorative of liberals.
We are engaged in the
<a href="http://www.uggbootonline.com.au/">UGG Boots</a> website. we supply high quality products, good service, and competitive price. We warmly welcome your visit and look forward to establish good relations of cooperation as well as friendship.Please visit <a href=http://www.uggbootonline.com.au/ > http://www.uggbootonline.com.au/<... if you are interested.Thanks!
Its nice to look into your valuable thoughts.I am very much inspired by your blog.So I look forward to see some more updates on your site.
When the door of happiness closes,http://shopcheaplv.com another opens but often times we look so long at the closed door that we don’t see the one which has been opened for us http://coachpurses4u.com